Both. If I’m gonna be toasting my bread, I like it smooth, otherwise it’s like rocks in snot. Crunchy is good for adding texture to my most delicious banana+mayo+pj sandwhiches. (bonus glass of milk)
oh gosh, ha ha ha ha. Make it chucky mayo and count me in.
horsebites said: Extra CRUNCHY!!!!!!! I don’t give a fuck if that shit was one giant peanut in a jar!!!
Get the mix your own peanut butter It has all the peanuts on the top, and some Peanutoil, then dump in extra peanuts & mix. Or for the smooth lovers just use the oil, win win.
Funny story about crunchy peanut butter with me...
When I was little and going to day care during the summer, my mom always packed my lunch of a pb&j and pudding cups or something like that.
I’ve always preferred creamy and thought that this day was odd because I had crunchy on my sandwich. Then, about an hour or so later I realized I was missing a tooth.
I ate my tooth because I thought it was a peanut in my peanut butter.
quixotic said: Funny story about crunchy peanut butter with me...
When I was little and going to day care during the summer, my mom always packed my lunch of a pb&j and pudding cups or something like that.
I’ve always preferred creamy and thought that this day was odd because I had crunchy on my sandwich. Then, about an hour or so later I realized I was missing a tooth.
I ate my tooth because I thought it was a peanut in my peanut butter.
I still prefer creamy.
Did you sift for it later so you could get money from the tooth fairy?
quixotic said: Funny story about crunchy peanut butter with me...
When I was little and going to day care during the summer, my mom always packed my lunch of a pb&j and pudding cups or something like that.
I’ve always preferred creamy and thought that this day was odd because I had crunchy on my sandwich. Then, about an hour or so later I realized I was missing a tooth.
I ate my tooth because I thought it was a peanut in my peanut butter.
I still prefer creamy.
Did you sift for it later so you could get money from the tooth fairy?
Haha... no, I’m pretty I pulverized it, so I couldn’t
quixotic said: Funny story about crunchy peanut butter with me...
When I was little and going to day care during the summer, my mom always packed my lunch of a pb&j and pudding cups or something like that.
I’ve always preferred creamy and thought that this day was odd because I had crunchy on my sandwich. Then, about an hour or so later I realized I was missing a tooth.
I ate my tooth because I thought it was a peanut in my peanut butter.
I still prefer creamy.
Did you sift for it later so you could get money from the tooth fairy?
Haha... no, I’m pretty I pulverized it, so I couldn’t
Oh well. At least it didn’t come back and bite you in the ass.
quixotic said: Funny story about crunchy peanut butter with me...
When I was little and going to day care during the summer, my mom always packed my lunch of a pb&j and pudding cups or something like that.
I’ve always preferred creamy and thought that this day was odd because I had crunchy on my sandwich. Then, about an hour or so later I realized I was missing a tooth.
I ate my tooth because I thought it was a peanut in my peanut butter.
I still prefer creamy.
Did you sift for it later so you could get money from the tooth fairy?
Haha... no, I’m pretty I pulverized it, so I couldn’t
Oh well. At least it didn’t come back and bite you in the ass.
38 Comments
Cole said 6 months ago
quakerninja said 6 months ago
choosy moms choose abortion...uh I mean Crunchy. I like crunchy, and Jam over Jelly and also Toasted, And Crust haters can all choke and die.
nate gonz said 6 months ago
a pb&j isn’t meant to be chunky.
Kolby said 6 months ago
+100
Smooth all the way.
joeROOSTER said 6 months ago
if theres no jelly i go with the crunchy.
justgeoff said 6 months ago
crunchy Jif and strawberry preserves = yumfest '08
gameyy said 6 months ago
Both. If I’m gonna be toasting my bread, I like it smooth, otherwise it’s like rocks in snot. Crunchy is good for adding texture to my most delicious banana+mayo+pj sandwhiches. (bonus glass of milk)
kyleisez said 6 months ago
MAYO YOU SICK FUCK
Ouchless said 6 months ago
Creamy dudes, creamy. No jelly. Toasted lightly. Possibly add some marshmallow fluff.
horsebites said 6 months ago
Extra CRUNCHY!!!!!!! I don’t give a fuck if that shit was one giant peanut in a jar!!!
hideouscarwreck said 6 months ago
crunchy for sure
kyleisez said 6 months ago
nutella+crunchy peanut butter+bananas= gloriousness
gameyy said 6 months ago
Nevermind you Kyle, ye of little faith.
I DARE YOU TO TRY IT. It’s nothing short of glorious.
quakerninja said 6 months ago
oh gosh, ha ha ha ha. Make it chucky mayo and count me in.
Get the mix your own peanut butter It has all the peanuts on the top, and some Peanutoil, then dump in extra peanuts & mix. Or for the smooth lovers just use the oil, win win.
Joey said 6 months ago
RikkiB said 6 months ago
CRUNCHYYY!
And in a celery stick.
MickyMays said 6 months ago
crunchy. peanuts are awesome
horsebites said 6 months ago
Ooooh!!! So good! I love the log, no ants please.
RikkiB said 6 months ago
Hehehe did you call them celery boats?
kyleisez said 6 months ago
celery is the worst fucking thing ever, next to onions, fuckkkk
gameyy said 6 months ago
Well I guess you wouldn’t like my onion celery sandwiches slathered in mayo. Your loss man. Your loss.
dsprad said 6 months ago
Crunchy peanut butter with bananas between two slices of white bread will make my day.
quixotic said 6 months ago
Funny story about crunchy peanut butter with me...
When I was little and going to day care during the summer, my mom always packed my lunch of a pb&j and pudding cups or something like that.
I’ve always preferred creamy and thought that this day was odd because I had crunchy on my sandwich. Then, about an hour or so later I realized I was missing a tooth.
I ate my tooth because I thought it was a peanut in my peanut butter.
I still prefer creamy.
Weston said 6 months ago
Peter Pan creamy. Bama Grape Jelly. Mix it together in a bowl with a fork. Then place between two slices of sunbeam white bread.
Go Ape Shirts said 6 months ago
Did you sift for it later so you could get money from the tooth fairy?
Bernard Bael said 6 months ago
oh man I haven’t had nutella in ages which makes me a bit sad :[ but I do like mine crunchy and lol @ Go Ape
asdafkid said 6 months ago
i thought this was gonna be a thread about guitar amps, hhahaha
Davee Bee said 6 months ago
I dunno... Something about partially chewed peanuts albeit by a machine doesn’t sit well with me. Creamy ftw!
charbear said 6 months ago
extra crunchy
quixotic said 6 months ago
Haha... no, I’m pretty I pulverized it, so I couldn’t
Weston said 6 months ago
Oh well. At least it didn’t come back and bite you in the ass.
RikkiB said 6 months ago
boom boom tish!
skull with hair said 6 months ago
creamy, the dogs have an easier time licking it...
heavyprints said 6 months ago
LOL
j3concepts said 6 months ago
CHUNKY!
Smooth is for homosexual gophers.
beth said 6 months ago
HAHAHAHHAHAHHAAHHA......HAHAHAHHAHAHHAHHAHAHA
I like creamy because crunchy just reminds me that I am eating peanuts maybe if the crunchiness was rice crispies that would be rad!
hideouscarwreck said 6 months ago
i just woke up to a delicious crunchy peanut butter and banana sandwhich
:D
quixotic said 6 months ago
HA! Good point.